The short answerNo study has compared magnesium forms head-to-head for leg cramps. What matters most is a form your body absorbs well, that's low in downsides, and that you take every day.
Full disclosure: we make Cramp Defense®, a special form of magnesium malate. We'll tell you where other forms are a good choice too.
GlycinateMalateCitrateOxideChlorideSulfate
12MgMagnesium
How to choose
Three questions to ask about a magnesium supplement
1. Does it absorb?
Forms that dissolve well, like malate, glycinate and citrate, are absorbed more completely than oxide and sulfate.1 If it isn't absorbed, it can't reach your muscles.
2. Does it have any downsides?
Downsides come in a few kinds. Side effects: loose stools or an upset stomach (citrate and sulfate are sold as laxatives), or drowsiness from forms like glycinate. Taste: some forms are very bitter. Convenience: some only come as liquids, flakes or sprays. If a magnesium is unpleasant to take, you won't keep taking it.
3. Am I willing to take it daily to prevent cramps?
Magnesium works over days and weeks, not minutes. Pick a dose and pill size you can stick with, and give it at least two weeks.
At a glance
The common forms, mapped
Higher is better absorbed. Further right means fewer downsides: side effects (loose stools, upset stomach, drowsiness), bad taste, or an inconvenient form like a liquid or spray. Forms in the green corner are the easiest to take every day.
A general guide based on the NIH, published reviews and our own testing of Truemag®. Absorption and downsides vary from person to person.
Form by form
The pros and cons of each
Numbered in our order of fit for leg cramps: how well each one absorbs, how few downsides it has, and how easy it is to take every day.
1Cramp Defense® (Truemag®)
Our pick
Highly absorbedFew downsidesMade for daily use
A special form of magnesium malate: fully reacted and triple-milled for maximum absorption, without the laxative effect or drowsiness of other forms for most people. Small 70 mg capsules make it easy to take every day.*
2Malate (generic)
Well absorbedGentle
Magnesium bound to malic acid, found naturally in apples. Malate is part of the cycle your cells use to make energy (ATP), which muscles need to relax. The best absorbed of five forms in one 2019 animal study.6 Quality varies by brand, and some products blend it with cheaper forms like oxide.
3Glycinate
Well absorbedGentle on the stomachCan cause drowsiness
Magnesium bound to glycine, an amino acid with a calming effect. That's why it's popular at bedtime, but it can make some people drowsy, which is a downside during the day. Often sold in large capsules or high doses, so check the label.
4Citrate
Well absorbedLaxative at higher doses
Absorbed well, but it's also sold as a laxative. Fine at low doses if your stomach agrees.
5Oxide
Less absorbedLoosens stools
The cheapest and most common, with the most magnesium per pill but lower absorption. It's the form used in the encouraging 2021 cramp trial.3
6Chloride
Well absorbedBitter tasteNot in capsules
Absorbed well, according to the NIH.1 But it's very bitter and draws in moisture, so it can't be put in a capsule. You'll mostly find it in liquids, flakes and sprays.
7Sulfate & sprays
Laxative if swallowedSkin absorption unproven
Epsom salt baths and magnesium oils feel soothing, but a 2017 review found no good evidence that magnesium gets through the skin.4
The most-asked question
Glycinate or malate for leg cramps?
Glycinate
Bound to
Glycine, an amino acid
Extra role
Calming; popular for sleep
Absorption
Good
Digestive
Gentle for most
Drowsiness
Can cause it
Cramp trials
None found
Malate (generic)
Bound to
Malic acid, found in apples
Extra role
Part of the muscle energy (ATP) cycle
Absorption
Good; varies by brand
Digestive
Gentle for most
Drowsiness
Not typical
Cramp trials
None found
A special form of malate
Cramp Defense®
Bound to
Malic acid, as Truemag®: fully reacted, triple-milled
Extra role
Part of the muscle energy (ATP) cycle
Absorption
Made for maximum absorption
Digestive
No laxative effect for most people
Drowsiness
Not typical
Dose
Small 70 mg capsules, easy to adjust
Our honest take: glycinate and malate are both good forms, and neither has been proven better for cramps. Glycinate can make some people drowsy, which may be welcome at bedtime but not during the day. If you already take glycinate and your cramps are gone, keep taking it. Cramp Defense® is our special form of malate, made for maximum absorption with few downsides, in small 70 mg capsules so you can find the lowest dose that works.*
How much
Start low and stay under the limit
Adults shouldn't take more than 350 mg of magnesium a day from supplements unless a doctor says so. Too much mostly causes diarrhea.2
Take it with food, and add more only if you need to
Check with your doctor first if you have kidney disease or take antibiotics, osteoporosis drugs or water pills
Does any of it work?
What the research shows about magnesium and cramps
The cautious view5trials in a 2020 Cochrane review
A 2020 Cochrane review of 5 trials in older adults found magnesium unlikely to meaningfully prevent cramps on average. The trials didn't check who was actually low in magnesium.5
The encouraging view175adults in a 2021 trial
A 2021 trial of 175 adults with night cramps found a larger drop in cramp duration and better sleep with magnesium than with placebo.3
What our customers tell us8 in 10say their cramps stop
About 8 in 10 say their cramps stop and 1 in 10 see them get milder. That's customer feedback, not a clinical trial.
If you'd like to try malate
Cramp Defense®, magnesium made for night leg cramps
Gentle magnesium malate (Truemag®), with malate for muscle energy
No study has compared forms head-to-head for cramps. Choose one your body absorbs well, that's low in downsides (no laxative effect, drowsiness or bitter taste) and that you'll take every day. Malate and glycinate both fit. Oxide is the least absorbed, and citrate and sulfate can act as laxatives.
How long does magnesium take to work?
Magnesium works over days and weeks, not minutes. Take it every day and give it at least two weeks before you judge whether it helps.
How much magnesium should I take?
Adults shouldn't take more than 350 mg a day from supplements unless a doctor says so. Start low, take it with food and add more only if you need to. Cramp Defense® comes in small 70 mg capsules so you can find the lowest dose that works.
Will magnesium upset my stomach?
Some forms can. Citrate, sulfate and oxide are known for loosening stools, and too much of any form can cause diarrhea. Truemag® is made to have no laxative effect for most people.
Is it safe with my medication?
Check with your doctor or pharmacist first, especially if you have kidney disease or take antibiotics, osteoporosis drugs or water pills.
Is Cramp Defense a subscription?
No. The trial size is a one-time purchase.
Who are you?
We're MgBRIGHT LLC, a small American company that has made Cramp Defense® since 2011. We make one product: Truemag®, a special form of magnesium malate made for maximum absorption with few downsides.
It's made in the USA, we hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau, we've sold more than 1,000,000 bottles, and every order is backed by our 120-day money-back guarantee.
NIH Office of Dietary Supplements. Magnesium fact sheet for health professionals. NIH
Costello R, et al. Call for re-evaluation of the tolerable upper intake level for magnesium supplementation in adults. Adv Nutr. 2023 (describes the 350 mg/day limit). PubMed
Barna O, et al. Magnesium oxide monohydrate in the treatment of nocturnal leg cramps. Nutr J. 2021. Full text
Gröber U, et al. Myth or reality: transdermal magnesium? Nutrients. 2017. PMC
Garrison SR, et al. Magnesium for skeletal muscle cramps. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020. PubMed
Uysal N, et al. Timeline (bioavailability) of magnesium compounds in hours: which magnesium compound works best? Biol Trace Elem Res. 2019 (animal study). PubMed
General information, not medical advice. *These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.